By The Writers' Room at Herb & Lou's
Somewhere in a conference room that four people refuse to call a writers' room, an argument has been running since the day we canned our first cocktail: what, exactly, is a THC cocktail, and why does everyone on the internet explain it wrong? We finally put the whole panel on the record — Lou, Herb, Mary, and Jane — because they were going to argue about it anyway, and because between the four of them they cover every question you were about to type into a search bar. What follows is the transcript, lightly cleaned up for language and, where legally necessary, annotated by Herb.
What Is a THC Cocktail? (The Short Answer)
A THC cocktail is a cocktail-style drink made with hemp-derived THC instead of alcohol. Herb & Lou's cans contain 8mg of hemp-derived delta-9 THC, zero alcohol, and the flavor of an actual cocktail. Hemp-derived delta-9 is federally legal under the 2018 Farm Bill, though state laws vary — so these are for adults 21+, where permitted.
That's the definition everyone on the panel signed off on, which took four meetings. The longer answer is that THC cocktails sit in a genuinely new spot: they're built like beverages, they behave socially like cocktails, and they're regulated like hemp. If you want the full picture — what's in the can, how it compares to a drink with liquor in it, how it compares to an edible, and how to serve it without embarrassing yourself — the panel has thoughts. The panel always has thoughts.
Meet the Panel (They Did Not Approve That Word Either)
- Lou — deadpan realist, decades of barstool seniority, namesake of Lou's Damn Right I'm Old Fashioned. Assigned topic: THC drinks vs. alcohol. Assigned himself: everything.
- Herb — fastidious accountant, keeper of the receipts, unbothered owner of Herb's Very Manly Peach Bellini. Covers what's actually in the can.
- Mary — unfiltered New Yorker, M Train Espresso Martini. Covers zero-proof culture, whether you asked or not.
- Jane — ice-cold socialite, Fancy Shmancy Pomegranate Cosmopolitan. Covers hosting, seating, and your shortcomings as a host.
Lou on THC Drinks vs. Alcohol: "Different Tools. Learn the Difference."
Lou has spent more evenings on a barstool than most people have spent indoors, so we let him take the comparison question. His opening statement: "Everybody writing about this online has clearly never enjoyed anything in their life. They compare proof numbers like it's a boxing tally. Wrong question."
Here's Lou's actual breakdown, which is — annoyingly — correct:
- The ritual is the same. A cocktail was never about the proof. It's the sit-down. The glass. The first sip while somebody finishes a story badly. A THC cocktail keeps all of that — you pour it, you pace it, you argue over it.
- The ingredient is different. Alcohol is alcohol. A THC cocktail is zero proof — no alcohol at all — with hemp-derived delta-9 THC instead. THC is its own thing, not a whiskey substitute, and Lou would like you to stop asking him to rank them. "It's not a replacement. It's a different tool. You don't ask a wrench to be a hammer."
- The experience is personal. How any THC drink lands depends on you — your tolerance, your dinner, your evening. Which is exactly why the house rule exists: start low, go slow. Have one, give it real time, and reassess before you even think about a second.
- The non-negotiables carry over. "And no, you don't drive after one. Same rule as the bar. I can't believe this needs saying, and yet here's a bullet point."
One more Lou ruling before we dragged him off the topic: "The best thing about a zero-proof cocktail is the liquor never gets a seat at the argument. I keep score when people talk. I like a fair fight."
Herb on What's Actually in the Can (He Brought Receipts)
Herb does not do vibes. Herb does line items. Here's his audit of the can, in the order the questions actually get asked.
Hemp-derived delta-9 THC, per the 2018 Farm Bill
The THC in a Herb & Lou's can is delta-9 THC derived from hemp. Under the 2018 Farm Bill, hemp — cannabis containing no more than 0.3% delta-9 THC by dry weight — is federally legal, which is what makes hemp-derived THC beverages possible to sell and ship in the first place. Herb's annotation: "Federal is one column. States are fifty other columns, and they do not reconcile. See the shipping section below, which I insisted on."
Nano-emulsification, explained like an accountant
THC is naturally an oil, and oil famously refuses to blend with a sparkling beverage. Nano-emulsification is a formulation technique that breaks that oil into droplets small enough to disperse evenly through the liquid. Herb's summary: "It means the can is consistent. The 8mg on the label is the 8mg in the liquid, top of the can to bottom, every can, and a third-party lab checks our work. I reconcile the label to the liquid. That is the entire technology as far as my department is concerned." No mystery pockets, no roulette. The drink also tastes like a cocktail instead of a chemistry set, which Herb classifies under "goodwill."
How a canned THC cocktail differs from an edible
The panel's consensus, delivered experientially, because that's the honest way to talk about it:
- Portioning. One can is one clearly labeled 8mg serving. An edible is frequently a geometry problem — Herb has watched a grown man divide a brownie into ninths with a butter knife and pure hope. "A can is self-auditing. One can. 8mg. Done."
- Ritual. You sip a cocktail over the better part of an hour. It participates in the evening — it's in the toast, it's on the coaster, it's in your hand while you make your point. A gummy is over in four seconds and contributes nothing to the conversation.
- Pacing. A drink has a built-in speed limit: the sip. That doesn't change the golden rule — everyone's different, so whatever the format, start low, go slow, and give it real time before reassessing.
For the flavor-science wing of this topic — why these taste like actual cocktails — the panel refers you to our standing piece on what terpenes actually do in a drink.
Mary on Zero-Proof Culture: "It's Not a Trend. It's a Correction."
Mary would like it on the record that she likes bars. She likes a bartender named Sal who remembers her order and hates the same people she hates. What she doesn't like is the assumption that a night out has to run on liquor to count as a night out.
"Here's what changed," Mary says. "Ten years ago you ordered a club soda at a party and got a wellness check. Now half the menu at any decent bar is zero proof and nobody blinks. People figured out you can want the bar, the outfit, the argument about the jukebox — the whole production — without wanting the liquor. That's not a trend. That's a correction."
Zero proof, for the record, means exactly what it sounds like: no alcohol. What made THC cocktails the interesting corner of the zero-proof shelf is that they're still an adult drink in the fullest sense — something you choose on purpose, pace like a cocktail, and take seriously enough to pour into real glassware. Mary's etiquette ruling: "Nobody owes anybody an explanation of what's in their glass. You want my espresso martini story, buy me dinner." Her longer thoughts on why a drink is social infrastructure live in what makes a cannabis social drink actually social.
Jane on Hosting With THC Cocktails (A Frankly Generous Amount of Free Advice)
Jane hosts the way other people compete professionally. Her starter kit, offered "because watching amateurs suffer stopped being fun in the nineties":
- Chill the cans properly. Room-temperature cocktails are how reputations end.
- Pour into real glassware. The can is charming. The coupe is correct.
- Label everything. THC cocktails on one tray, non-THC options on another, clearly marked. Every guest knows exactly what they're holding. This is non-negotiable and Jane will not be charmed out of it.
- One can per guest to start. Wait, then reassess. "Pacing is elegance," Jane says. "Also it's the rule."
- Adults 21+ only, food on the table before the first pour, and rides planned before anyone opens anything.
Jane's complete hosting doctrine — seating politics included — got its own article, because she required it: Zero Proof, Full Send: hosting a cocktail night without the liquor.
Where THC Cocktails Are Legal to Ship (The Section Herb Made Us Include)
Herb insisted, so here it is, plainly. Federally, hemp-derived delta-9 THC products are legal under the 2018 Farm Bill. But states set their own rules on intoxicating hemp products, and those rules change often — some states allow them, some restrict them, some prohibit shipping entirely. We only ship where it's permitted, and everything we sell is for adults 21 and over, full stop. Herb's closing annotation: "Laws move faster than my ledger. Before you order — here or anywhere — check your own state's current rules. Consider that free advice from a man who bills hourly."
The Cocktails in Question
The panel's body of work, for reference: Lou's Old Fashioned (bitters, orange, oak, grievance), Mary's M Train Espresso Martini (double espresso, cream, attitude), Herb's Very Manly Peach Bellini (peach, sparkling, unimpeachable confidence), and Jane's Pomegranate Cosmopolitan (pomegranate, citrus, judgment). Each is 8mg of hemp-derived delta-9 THC, zero proof, $16.99 for a 4-pack. If you'd rather not choose — and Herb respects the diversified position — there's the Variety Pack, or you can browse the full lineup in The Cans. On the dosing question specifically, Herb wrote an entire follow-up: The 8mg Question.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are THC drinks legal?
Hemp-derived delta-9 THC drinks are federally legal under the 2018 Farm Bill, which legalized hemp containing no more than 0.3% delta-9 THC by dry weight. State laws vary widely and change often, so check your state's current rules. Herb & Lou's ships only where permitted, and only to adults 21+.
Will a THC cocktail get me drunk?
No — there's no alcohol in the can, so "drunk" is off the table entirely. THC is its own experience and it affects everyone differently, so treat it with the same adult respect you'd give any drink: start low, go slow, and don't drive afterward.
How many THC cocktails should I have?
Start with one. Each Herb & Lou's can is a single 8mg serving of hemp-derived delta-9 THC. Sip it like a cocktail, give it real time, and reassess before considering another. Tolerance is personal — your friend's pace is not your pace.
Do THC cocktails taste like cannabis?
Ours taste like the cocktails they're named after — espresso martini, old fashioned, bellini, cosmopolitan. That's the point of building them as cocktails first. Terpenes play a supporting role in aroma and character; the panel's full explainer on that is on the blog.
Can I mix THC cocktails with alcohol?
We don't recommend combining them. These are built to carry the evening on their own, zero proof. Pick a lane for the night — Lou insists, and for once the whole panel agrees.
How should I store them?
Cold, like any good cocktail, and always out of reach of children and pets. The cans are clearly labeled — keep them that way, and keep them to adults 21+.
Thirsty for the argument itself? The whole panel is canned and waiting in The Cans — or take one of everything with the Variety Pack and let your own table fight it out.
For adults 21+ only. Start low, go slow. Do not drive or operate machinery after use. Keep out of reach of children and pets. Hemp-derived delta-9 THC products are federally legal under the 2018 Farm Bill; state laws vary — check your local laws before ordering. FDA Disclaimer: These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
← Back to all opinions